What Buyers Actually Pay: PPA Prices Hidden in FERC EQR Filings
By Load Factor Team
Ask what a power purchase agreement costs and you will get three different answers, all called a PPA price: a marketplace offer, a signed-contract average, and a FERC filing showing what money actually changed hands. Those are not three estimates of one number, and most public discussion treats them as interchangeable. It should not.
The only one that records realized deals is the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's Electric Quarterly Report, the EQR. Every seller with market-based rate authority files it quarterly, contract by contract. If you want to know what buyers actually pay, that is where the evidence lives. But the EQR does not hand you a price. It hands you a compliance filing system, and the price is buried in fields sellers fill in inconsistently. This piece explains what is in those filings, what headline numbers hide, and how to read a PPA price without being misled by it.
Three prices, one label
Start with the three numbers confused most often.
First, offer prices. LevelTen Energy's index tracks the 25th percentile offer, the P25. In the third quarter of 2025, North American solar offers averaged $59.77 per MWh and wind $74.69 at P25. In the fourth quarter, solar rose 3.2 percent and wind dipped 1 percent, leaving both up nearly 9 percent year over year. These are asking prices, not signed deals.
Second, signed prices. Berkeley Lab's Utility-Scale Solar 2024 Edition found newly signed longer-term solar PPA prices averaged $35 per MWh, levelized in 2023 dollars. That is a different population: signed contracts, levelized over the contract life, in older dollars. Comparing $35 to $59.77 and concluding prices nearly doubled would be wrong.
Third, realized prices. EQR records show the quantity delivered and the charge billed each quarter, seller by seller, buyer by buyer. A realized price is what a buyer actually paid for what was actually delivered: the only one of the three that cannot be gamed by an asking price or smoothed by levelization, and the one almost nobody quotes, because extracting it means reading the filings contract by contract.
What an EQR filing actually contains
Each EQR contract record carries a product type, product name, quantity, units, and up to four rate fields: Rate, Rate Minimum, Rate Maximum, and Rate Description. Product type codes are blunt: CB cost-based, CR capacity reassignment, MB market-based, T transmission, NPU non-public utility, and Other. The rate description is free text, required when numeric fields do not specify the rate.
That bluntness is the first problem. FERC staff found 33 percent of second quarter 2017 transactions reported as "Other," most of them energy and capacity sales to RTOs and ISOs that staff would have expected as market-based. Any analysis that takes product type at face value inherits that error.
The second problem is the rate description. It is seller-written text. One seller writes "energy only" with a single number; another covers energy, capacity, renewable energy certificates, and ancillary services in one bundled rate; a third writes "market-based" and nothing else. The numeric field may be blank, a number, or a range. Two contracts at the same headline rate can buy different things, and two buying the same thing can look incomparable. The filing tells the truth only if you read the description, not just the number.
What the headline hides: geography
The regional spread alone kills any single national price. LevelTen's fourth quarter 2025 solar P25 offers ranged from $49 per MWh in ERCOT to $115 per MWh in ISO-NE, more than a twofold gap inside one country and one quarter.
| $/MWh | Solar P25 offer price ($/MWh) ($/MWh) |
|---|---|
| ISO-NE | 115 |
| PJM | 81.03 |
| MISO | 64.95 |
| CAISO | 62 |
| ERCOT | 49 |
Source: LevelTen Energy PPA Price Index, Q4 2025, as reported by pv magazine
Berkeley Lab's signed data agrees: 2023 solar market values averaged $45 per MWh nationally, from $27 in CAISO to $67 in ERCOT, and 2024 wind wholesale value ran from $10 in SPP to $40 in CAISO. Geography is not noise around a national price. It is the price.
Fuel adds another split: Berkeley Lab's wind PPA prices drifted from under $20 per MWh around 2018 to over $40 per MWh recently. Wind and solar prices move on different drivers, in different regions, on different timelines. A blended "renewables PPA price" averages away exactly what a buyer needs.
What the headline hides: product, term, and buyer
Product is the subtlest trap. A rate description may bundle energy with capacity, RECs, or tolling, or cover energy alone. Comparing a bundled price to an energy-only price and calling the second cheaper compares a meal to an ingredient. EQR data separates these only if each contract is classified by what its description actually says it buys, excluding ones that do not say enough. A smaller, honest sample beats a larger average built from unlike contracts.
Term is the second trap. LevelTen's index is an offer snapshot; Berkeley Lab's signed average is levelized over long contracts. A short-term realized price in a high-price quarter and a 20-year levelized price are both real, and neither substitutes for the other. State the term basis next to the number.
Buyer type is the third. Berkeley Lab notes corporate PPA pricing is underrepresented in its signed sample, which leans on utility deals. Corporate buyers negotiate shaped and 24/7 products priced on hourly matching, not flat energy. A series that underweights corporate deals misdescribes the marginal buyer.
Cleaning rules: what this piece does and does not do
Because EQR names and rate descriptions are seller-reported and inconsistent, no figure in this series is a raw average of filed numbers. The rules for Load Factor's EQR cuts are:
- Only contracts with a stated numeric rate and units enter a price average; vague descriptions count toward coverage, never toward price.
- Classify by product name plus rate description, not product type code; "Other" contracts are reclassified where possible, excluded from averages where not.
- Never average across product classes; capacity-only $/kW-month rates are never converted into $/MWh averages.
- Report realized prices (charge divided by delivered quantity) separately from contract rates: a rate is a promise, a realized price is a payment.
- Cross-check project status against EIA generator records so PPAs on unbuilt projects are not counted as realized generation.
- Flag affiliate transactions separately; they are not arm's-length price evidence.
These rules shrink the sample. That is the point. A benchmark built from unlike contracts is not approximately right. It is precisely wrong.
What Load Factor's EQR cuts add
Public series describe offers and signed deals. EQR cuts describe what changed hands, tied to the project that generated it and the buyer that paid for it: which offtakers pay above or below their regional benchmark, and which contract structures survive contact with delivery.
How to read a PPA price
Before trusting any PPA price, ask five questions. Is it an offer, a signed average, or a realized payment? Which ISO and which fuel? What does the rate actually buy: energy only, or a bundle? Over what term, and in what year's dollars? And whose deals are in the sample: utilities, corporates, or both? A price that cannot answer all five is not a benchmark. It is a headline.
The EQR filings contain the answers for readers willing to classify the product, read the description, separate promise from payment, and refuse the single average.
Sources
- Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Electric Quarterly Report Data Dictionary v3.4: contract fields including Product Type Name (CB, CR, MB, T, NPU, Other), Product Name, Quantity, Units, Rate, Rate Minimum, Rate Maximum, and Rate Description: https://ferc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-05/DataDictionary2017.pdf
- Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Order No. 770 and EQR Data Dictionary (RM12-3-000): product type definitions and contract data fields: https://permanent.fdlp.gov/websites/www.ferc.gov/2019/www.ferc.gov/whats-new/comm-meet/2012/111512/E-5.pdf
- Federal Energy Regulatory Commission staff presentation on EQR reporting (Dec 5, 2017): 33 percent of Q2 2017 transactions reported as "Other" product type, mostly energy and capacity sales to RTOs/ISOs: https://cms.ferc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-09/20171205125300-eqr-12-05-2017.pdf
- Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Utility-Scale Solar, 2024 Edition: newly signed longer-term PPA prices averaging $35/MWh levelized (2023 dollars); 2023 solar market value averaging $45/MWh nationally, $27/MWh in CAISO, $67/MWh in ERCOT: https://emp.lbl.gov/publications/utility-scale-solar-2024-edition
- Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Land-Based Wind Market Report 2024/2025 editions: wind PPA prices drifting from under $20/MWh around 2018 to over $40/MWh recently; 2024 wind wholesale value $10/MWh in SPP to $40/MWh in CAISO: https://eta-publications.lbl.gov/sites/default/files/land-based_wind_market_report_2024_edition_presentation.pdf
- LevelTen Energy, PPA Price Index Q3 2025, as reported by pv magazine: North American solar P25 $59.77/MWh, wind P25 $74.69/MWh: https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2025/10/14/procure-with-haste-as-solar-power-purchase-agreement-prices-rise-says-levelten-energy/
- LevelTen Energy, PPA Price Index Q4 2025, as reported by pv magazine: solar P25 by ISO (ISO-NE $115, PJM $81.03, MISO $64.95, CAISO $62, ERCOT $49 per MWh); solar up 3.2 percent quarter over quarter, wind down 1 percent, both up nearly 9 percent year over year: https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2026/01/30/uncertainty-looms-as-solar-ppa-prices-climb-for-second-straight-quarter/