Skip to content
LOAD FACTOR
Back to Insights
Policy & Regulation

FERC Order 2023: What Cluster Reform Means for Renewable Energy Developers

Published April 27, 2026 • 9 min read • Load Factor team
Share this
Listen

At the end of 2023, more than 2,600 GW of generation capacity sat in US interconnection queues — enough to power the country several times over — while the median time to complete an interconnection study had stretched beyond five years. FERC Order 2023, issued in July 2023 and effective for new applications from mid-2024, is the most significant reform to the US interconnection process in two decades. It will reshape how renewable energy projects move from queue application to commercial operation.

Understanding what changed — and what it means for active developers — requires unpacking a system that was not designed for today's volume of applications.

The Problem Order 2023 Was Designed to Fix

The serial interconnection study process that predated Order 2023 worked as follows: each new application entered a queue and received a study that assumed all projects ahead of it in the queue were built out. This created a fundamental problem. The vast majority of projects in the queue ahead of any given applicant were never going to be built — LBNL research shows that roughly 75–80% of projects that enter US queues ultimately withdraw. But each study still modeled them as built, inflating cost estimates for later entrants and generating studies for phantom projects that then had to be redone when those projects withdrew.

The result was a cascading queue collapse problem: withdrawals triggered restudy obligations for remaining projects, which consumed study resources and extended timelines, which encouraged more withdrawals, which required more restudies. PJM and MISO each went through periods where their study backlogs grew faster than their study capacity could address them.

FERC's diagnosis: the serial, first-come-first-served methodology was the structural cause of the backlog. The fix was cluster-based processing.

How Cluster Processing Works

Under Order 2023, ISOs must group new interconnection applications received during a defined window (typically six months) into a cluster and study them simultaneously. Key changes include:

  • Simultaneous study of clustered applications. All projects in a cluster are studied together, modeling their combined impact on the transmission system. This eliminates the phantom-project inflation problem because cost estimates reflect only the projects actually in the current study group.
  • Cluster-based cost allocation. Transmission upgrade costs are allocated across all projects in a cluster that benefit from a given upgrade, rather than loaded onto the first entrant that triggered the upgrade need. This distributes study costs more fairly and reduces the incentive for speculative queue applications that front-run transmission investment.
  • Minimum financial requirements at application. Order 2023 requires applicants to demonstrate site control (executed lease or option, or fee ownership) and post a deposit of $5,000 per MW for transmission-level projects. This is designed to reduce speculative applications from developers who have not yet secured land.
  • Study timeline mandates. ISOs must complete interconnection studies within defined windows or face financial penalties. The intent is to create accountability for study delays that have historically extended timelines by years.
  • Withdrawal penalties. Projects that withdraw after entering a cluster must pay a portion of study costs, reducing the current economics of speculative queue entry and planned withdrawal.

ISO-by-ISO Implementation Status

ISOs had different deadlines for compliance with Order 2023, and they entered reform from very different baseline conditions:

ISO/RTOOrder 2023 Compliance DatePrior MethodologyKey Implementation Notes
MISOMid-2025Generator Interconnection Procedures (serial)Already used cycle-based studies; Order 2023 formalizes cluster approach
PJMMid-2025Serial queue, heavily backloggedLargest backlog impact; PJM requested and received partial compliance waiver
CAISOMid-2025Cluster studies (pre-existing)Already cluster-based; compliance adjustments are incremental
ERCOTExemptNon-FERC (state jurisdiction)ERCOT is not subject to FERC Order 2023
SPPMid-2024Serial queueTransitioning; new applications from mid-2024 enter cluster framework
NYISOMid-2025Serial queueCompliance in progress
ISO-NEMid-2025Serial queueCompliance in progress

CAISO had already adopted a cluster study methodology years before Order 2023, which is why its queue, while large, has not experienced the same study collapse dynamics as PJM. ERCOT is not subject to FERC jurisdiction and will not implement Order 2023 — its interconnection process operates under Texas PUC oversight.

What This Means for Active Developers

For developers with projects already in queue before Order 2023's compliance dates, the transition creates a two-tier system: existing projects proceed under the old rules while new applications enter the cluster framework. This has several practical implications:

  • Existing queue positions retain value — but for a limited window. Projects that entered the queue before Order 2023 compliance dates may complete their studies under the serial methodology. In markets with large backlogs (PJM), this could mean years of continued serial processing before the queue clears to all-cluster applications.
  • New applications face higher upfront costs. The site control requirement and $5,000/MW deposit filter out purely speculative applicants. Developers who have not secured land before applying can no longer hold a queue position while they pursue options.
  • Cluster composition matters for cost allocation. Projects that are clustered together share transmission upgrade costs. A developer whose project is in a cluster with several high-MW projects that require major transmission upgrades may face higher allocated costs than a developer in a smaller cluster with modest upgrade needs. Understanding who else is in your cluster, and what transmission constraints they expose, becomes a material consideration.
  • Withdrawal economics have changed. The financial penalties for withdrawal after cluster formation reduce the attractiveness of queue positions as options. This is by design — FERC explicitly intended to reduce speculative applications — but it also changes how developers should evaluate project viability before submitting.

Why This Matters for Developers and Investors

Order 2023 does not immediately reduce study timelines for the existing backlog. Projects already in queue will not move faster simply because FERC issued a new order. What will change — gradually — is the quality of cost estimates and the composition of active queue applicants.

Cluster processing should reduce phantom-project inflation in cost estimates. When only genuinely funded, site-controlled projects are in the cluster, the cost estimates for transmission upgrades will be less inflated by dead projects that will never build out. This makes the cost estimates more reliable inputs for investment committee decisions.

For investors who source deals from the queue, Order 2023 creates a filtering effect that concentrates capital-backed projects in the active pipeline. The speculative applications that historically padded queue counts are less likely to appear in post-reform cohorts. A queue with fewer but better-capitalized applicants is a queue where individual project identification carries higher signal value.

Understanding which projects entered a queue under pre-reform versus post-reform rules also matters for due diligence. Pre-reform queue positions in markets with large backlogs (PJM) may carry more timeline risk than the queue date alone suggests. Post-reform cluster entries have different cost allocation dynamics and withdrawal economics that require separate analysis.

Conclusion

FERC Order 2023 is a structural reform, not a quick fix. It will take several cluster cycles — likely 2026 through 2028 — before its effects on study timelines and queue composition become fully visible. In the interim, developers and investors are navigating a transition period where old-queue and new-queue projects coexist under different rules.

For the broader context on how US interconnection queues work — including the study process that Order 2023 is reforming — see The US Interconnection Queue by the Numbers. For the withdrawal-rate data that motivated FERC's reform, see Interconnection Queue Withdrawal Rates: What Withdrawn Projects Reveal.

Load Factor tracks queue project status, study cycle vintage, and developer identity across all major US ISOs. Browse projects to see which queue cohorts are most active in each market.

Share this

Load Factor tracks 38,000+ interconnection queue projects, withdrawn included, across 16 North American markets, with the evidence behind every developer it names.

Next step

See your market in 30 minutes.

A walkthrough of the projects, developers and evidence in the markets you work in.

Get the weekly brief

Queue movement, newly identified developers and the week’s deals, every Monday. Read past issues

Book a 30-min walkthrough