Skip to content
LOAD FACTOR
Back to Insights
Queue Data

Interconnection Queue Withdrawal Rates: What Withdrawn Projects Reveal

Published April 8, 2026 • 9 min read • Load Factor team
Share this

The US interconnection queue contains more dead projects than live ones. That is not a bug - it is a feature of how interconnection works. Projects enter the queue years before commercial viability is established, and many never reach it. Understanding the withdrawal pattern is essential context for interpreting what the active queue actually represents.

Load Factor's database includes 10,848 withdrawn projects across its 16 tracked ISOs. That is roughly 26% of the total project count - more than one in four queue entries has been withdrawn. In some ISOs, the rate is far higher.

What "withdrawn" means in queue data

A withdrawal occurs when the developer (or project entity) formally notifies the ISO that it is discontinuing the interconnection application. The application is removed from active study, and the queue position is released.

Withdrawals happen at multiple stages:

  • Pre-study withdrawal - Before any interconnection study begins. The developer may have failed to secure land rights, couldn't raise capital, or faced a competing priority.
  • Mid-study withdrawal - During the interconnection study process. The study results often reveal upgrade costs that make the project economically unviable at the proposed size or location.
  • Post-study withdrawal - After receiving study results. The developer reviewed the network upgrade obligations and elected not to proceed.
  • GIA withdrawal - A project that reached GIA stage but could not meet construction milestones. Rare; represents a significant sunk cost.

The most common trigger is study results. When an interconnection study assigns a project a large network upgrade obligation - potentially hundreds of millions of dollars - developers routinely withdraw rather than accept that obligation. This is the rational response to a queue process where upgrade costs are only known after years of study.

ISO-by-ISO withdrawal analysis

PJM has the highest withdrawal profile of any major US ISO in Load Factor's database.

ISOActive projectsWithdrawn projectsWithdrawal rate
PJM10,875High (estimated)~67% of all applications
MISO5,545SignificantSubstantial
ERCOT3,089PresentLower than PJM
CAISO2,448PresentModerate
SPP2,830PresentModerate
NYISO1,419PresentPresent

PJM: the withdrawal crisis

PJM's interconnection reform has been driven in large part by its withdrawal problem. A study by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory found that approximately 67% of projects entering the PJM queue between 2000 and 2017 ultimately withdrew. More recent cohorts have shown even higher withdrawal rates in early study phases.

The pattern creates a structural problem: a large number of speculative applications enter the queue, blocking queue positions and requiring transmission network upgrade studies that are never built. This imposes costs and delays on projects that do intend to develop.

PJM's reforms - including increased financial deposit requirements (originally $10,000, now substantially higher for larger projects) and the cluster study approach - were designed to reduce speculative queue entry. The impact is visible in more recent application cohorts, but the withdrawn project backlog remains in the historical record.

Load Factor flags withdrawn projects explicitly. Analyses that don't filter withdrawn applications will overstate the active development pipeline significantly.

Why projects withdraw: the five main reasons

1. Unacceptable network upgrade costs. Interconnection studies assign the cost of required transmission upgrades to the interconnection customer. When those costs are disproportionate to project economics - particularly for remote sites or large projects requiring significant new transmission - withdrawal is the rational outcome.

2. Failed land acquisition. A developer may have secured an option on land at the time of queue application but fail to convert that option to a long-term lease. Without land rights, the project cannot proceed regardless of interconnection cost.

3. Offtake unavailability. Without a power purchase agreement or a viable merchant revenue strategy, the project cannot be financed. Developers who cannot secure offtake within the project's financial viability window withdraw.

4. Queue position superseded. Projects ahead in the queue receive priority in interconnection study sequencing. If multiple large projects ahead of a given application require the same upgrade, the later application's feasibility depends on the earlier projects' outcomes. Queue position deterioration can trigger withdrawal.

5. Capital and corporate strategy changes. Developer priorities change. Portfolio rebalancing, capital constraints, corporate M&A, and strategic pivots all affect which projects get pushed forward and which are abandoned.

What withdrawn projects tell us about active projects

The withdrawal data is not merely historical context - it actively informs how to interpret the active queue.

Active projects are not all equivalent. A project that has completed interconnection studies, has an executed GIA, has land rights, and has an executed PPA is fundamentally different from a project that entered the queue two years ago and has only paid the initial deposit. Both appear in "active" queue counts.

Queue depth overstates near-term development. The total MW in the US active queue - often reported in headlines as a measure of the clean energy pipeline - includes speculative early-stage applications alongside advanced projects. The headline number is real but not directly convertible to "MW that will be built."

Geography filters partially resolve this. The fraction of active projects that reach commercial operation varies by ISO and by vintage. MISO's cluster study reforms, PJM's deposit increases, and ERCOT's relatively faster study timeline all affect the conversion rate from queue application to commercial operation.

The FERC Order 2023 context

FERC Order 2023, finalized in 2023, overhauled interconnection rules for FERC-jurisdictional ISOs (PJM, MISO, SPP, ISO-NE, NYISO, CAISO). Key provisions relevant to withdrawal rates:

Cluster study approach. Projects in the same study window are studied together rather than sequentially. Cost responsibility for network upgrades is shared among a study cluster rather than assigned solely to the first project that triggers a given upgrade. This changes the incentive to withdraw when a project's study reveals large upgrade obligations.

Increased financial requirements. Higher initial deposits and milestone payments were required to maintain a queue position. This raises the cost of speculative queue entry, reducing - though not eliminating - the flood of applications that never intend to develop.

Study cycle timelines. Order 2023 set mandatory timelines for study completion. Persistent delays in PJM's and MISO's study processes have been a major driver of withdrawal - projects that enter the queue expecting a 2-year study cycle face 5-year or longer actual timelines, during which development costs accumulate and market conditions change.

Load Factor tracks withdrawn projects as a historical record, not as active pipeline. The distinction is flagged explicitly in the database and in the browse interface.

ERCOT's withdrawal profile

ERCOT's withdrawal rate is lower than PJM's by most measures, which is consistent with the broader pattern of ERCOT being a more tractable development market.

ERCOT's study process has generally been faster than PJM's. Texas's single-state footprint means the interconnection customer deals with ERCOT as both the ISO and the operator, without the multi-utility transmission owner complexity that characterizes PJM.

That said, ERCOT is not withdrawal-free. Storage applications - which ERCOT receives at very high volume - have a meaningful withdrawal rate. Speculative storage applications in particularly attractive ERCOT pricing zones have been submitted in large numbers. A portion of these withdraw when study results clarify the upgrade obligations.

What investors should know about withdrawal-adjusted pipeline

For investors and lenders evaluating the "real" renewable energy development pipeline in a given market, withdrawal-adjusted analysis is the correct starting point.

The question is not "how many MW are in the queue" but "how many MW in the queue meet the criteria that predict successful development":

  • GIA executed or in progress (post-study commitment)
  • Land rights documented (lease or ownership)
  • Offtake in place or identifiable
  • Developer has operating history in the market

Load Factor's project detail pages include the available evidence on each of these dimensions. A project whose developer two sources agree on, with a GIA date and a known land counterparty, is a fundamentally different intelligence asset than an early-stage application with only a queue number.

Frequently Asked Questions

What percentage of US interconnection queue projects are withdrawn? Load Factor tracks 10,848 withdrawn projects across 16 ISOs. This represents approximately 26% of total tracked applications. PJM's historical withdrawal rate is particularly high - studies have found approximately 67% of PJM queue entrants from prior cohorts withdrew before reaching commercial operation.

Why do so many interconnection queue projects get withdrawn? The most common reason is unacceptable network upgrade costs revealed by interconnection studies. Projects also withdraw due to failed land acquisition, inability to secure offtake, queue position deterioration as projects ahead require the same upgrades, and corporate strategy changes.

Does Load Factor include withdrawn projects in its counts? Withdrawn projects are tracked separately in Load Factor's database and are excluded from active project counts by default. The browse interface filters out withdrawn projects. Users who need historical withdrawal data can query withdrawn status explicitly.

What is FERC Order 2023 and how does it affect withdrawal rates? FERC Order 2023 overhauled interconnection rules for FERC-jurisdictional ISOs. It introduced cluster study methodology (spreading upgrade costs across a study cohort), higher financial deposit requirements (discouraging speculative entry), and mandatory study timelines. These changes are expected to reduce withdrawal rates in future application cohorts, but the historical backlog of withdrawn projects remains in queue databases.

How should investors interpret active queue MW numbers? Active queue MW significantly overstates near-term buildable capacity. A withdrawal-adjusted analysis filters to projects with completed studies, executed GIAs, and documented land rights to estimate the realistic near-term development pipeline. Load Factor's project-level evidence helps identify which active projects meet these criteria.

Methodology

Withdrawn project count (10,848) reflects Load Factor's total database including historical records. Active project count (41,692) includes all non-withdrawn projects across 16 ISOs. Withdrawal rates are calculated as withdrawn / (withdrawn + active) for each ISO. PJM withdrawal rate estimate (~67%) draws on Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory interconnection research. FERC Order 2023 analysis based on FERC public rulemaking record.

Conclusion

Withdrawal is not a pathology - it is the market clearing mechanism for an interconnection process that requires commitment before full cost information is available. Understanding the withdrawal pattern, the ISO-by-ISO variation, and the project characteristics that predict completion is essential context for any serious analysis of the US renewable energy pipeline.

Browse active queue projects with evidence-backed developer attribution. For the PJM context where withdrawal rates are most acute, read The PJM Interconnection Queue Problem.

Share this

Load Factor tracks 38,000+ interconnection queue projects, withdrawn included, across 16 North American markets, with the evidence behind every developer it names.

Next step

See your market in 30 minutes.

A walkthrough of the projects, developers and evidence in the markets you work in.

Get the weekly brief

Queue movement, newly identified developers and the week’s deals, every Monday. Read past issues

Book a 30-min walkthrough